VII

Curriculum Development in

Population Education

Saroj Bala Yadav

 

Introduction

The school curriculum of a country, like its Constitution, reflects the ethos of that country as also its chief concerns. The values enshrined in our Constitution points towards the development of a pluralist open society and a state which is secular, democratic and socialist in nature. The school curriculum should reflect these aims and values in its structure, content, implied methodology - in fact, in its entire design.

The term "curriculum" is derived from the Latin world "currere", which means "run" and its signifies "a run way" or course which is run to reach a goal. In education, it is generally identified with a course of studies or list of subjects prescribed for a course. In fact a list of subjects forms only a part of the curriculum and not whole of it. A curriculum means the total situation (or all situations) selected and organized by the institutions and made available to the teacher to operate and translate the ultimate aim of education into reality. The Secondary Education Commission, (1953) points out that a curriculum "does not mean only the academic subjects traditionally taught in the school but it includes the totality of experiences that a pupil receives through the manifold activities that go on in the school, in the class room, library, laboratory, workshop, playground and numerous informal contacts between teachers and pupils".

Thus the term curriculum, in its broad sense, refers to all the planned learning activities or experiences provided by an educational programme to a group of learners or target audience. As such it may include objectives, content, learning activities, materials, teaching aids and evaluation means and tools. In its narrow sense a curriculum may refer solely to the core contents or content outline of a particular programme or field.

Curriculum Development in Population Education.

Curriculum development is the most important component of an educational innovation, namely, Population Education. The introduction of population issues in the school curriculum, the explanation of the inter-relationships between a wide range of social phenomena both at micro and the macro levels, the explicit attention to the preparation of students for their future role as adult decision makers in their families, the community and the nation. This innovation can have an impact on curriculum design and instruction and make it possible to assert that population education can become both a stimulus to and a support for wide-spread educational reform.

It is through the curricular materials that the future citizens receive population education messages. It aims at the development of awareness and attitudes that will make learners to develop responsible behaviour in the context of population issues.

Why Population Education in Schools?

The onus of meeting the challenge of population growth rests on the young people who will constitute the adult population in the coming two to three decades. It is their reproductive behaviour when they become adults, which is going to affect considerably the population situation in future. In order to achieve population stabilization, the future parents, who are most important segment of society, must be involved. Their changed attitude towards family size is vital. Population education through the school system could be a potent instrument for developing these attitudes and competencies among this group and help them to take a rational decision. Different people have different opinion about the introduction of population education at different grade levels. Some of the arguments given for the introduction of population education at the elementary stage in India are as follows:

(i) Elementary stage has the highest enrolment. Children drop-out as they go up higher in the educational ladder. Introducing population education at this stage will benefit larger number of children.

(ii) Elementary school curriculum generally provides flexibility for introducing new concerns. Since there is no public examination at this stage, a greater number of opportunities for the use of experimental materials are available.

(iii) A number of research studies have indicated that it is easy to bring about change in attitudes at this formative stage.

(iv) Primary school teachers still play an important role in the rural areas. Their exposure to population related issues will help both students and the community at large in changing their attitude and behaviour in a right direction.

Those who argue for the introduction of population education at the secondary level give the following reasons:

(i) Students at this stage are in the process of growing up. These are the students who are already or will be taking decisions regarding marriage and reproductive behaviour very shortly. Education in matters related to adolescent reproductive health and other population related issues is of immediate relevance.

(ii) Students at this stage can grasp and understand population issues in greater depth.

(iii) The number of teachers to be trained in population education is comparatively smaller.

It would be better if population education is introduced at all the stages of school education. Efforts should be made to reach even those who are not in the school.

Approaches to Curriculum Development in Population Education

The following two approaches are being followed in most of the countries, for the development of curriculum in population education. One approach is Separate Subject approach and the other is Integrated Approach.

Separate Subject Approach

In the first approach, population education becomes a subject area along with other subjects taught at one or more grade levels. A separate subject affords the greatest possibility of systematic and sustained learning. Some countries have started thinking of introducing population education as a separate subject at the secondary level. For example, Philippines and Thailand are offering it as a separate elective course at secondary level. Although this approach is much effective and the chances of dilution and diffusion are less but it has not been put into practice in most of the countrie as Population Education is multi-disciplinary in nature and draws its content from various subjects. Secondly, school time tables are already over crowded and teachers find it difficult to accommodate a new course. Thirdly, new teachers will be required if it is introduced as a separate course. Most of the countries have, therefore, used an integrated approach to include population education concepts in different school subjects.

Integrated Approach

A survey of the sparse literature in the field and discussion with its proponents suggest that separate population education course or a series of courses to be included at elementary and secondary stages is not the most appropriate way to develop the necessary awareness. The curriculum is already crowded, the demand from the traditional disciplines generally reduced the possibility of adding a new population course. Further children will learn better if they are confronted with population related issues both throughout their school curriculum and during their entire period of schooling". Population education is multi disciplinary in nature and related to various subject/areas. The National Seminar on Population Education held at Bombay in 1969 also recommended "Population Education should be introduced into the curriculum of schools and colleges by including it in so far as it may be possible, in the areas of study such as Social Studies, Sciences, Health Education, Mathematics, Languages etc. In fact this serninar was of the view that it may be possible to achieve all the objectives in view by including population education suitably in the curricula of appropriate subjects already included in the curriculum."

Integration of population education in different school subjects can be possible in two ways:

i) Unit Approach : In this approach new units relating to population education are developed and added to the existing units in the course/syllabus of the subject area. This type of approach is adopted in countries like Philippines, the Republic of Korea and Thailand. The subjects usually chosen for the inclusion of population education units are Social Sciences, General Sciences, Biology, Mathematics, Home Economics, Health Education, Physical Education and Geography;

ii) Infusion Approach : This approach implies inclusion of population education concepts and data into the normal process of instruction throughout the curriculum without having to develop separate course of new units. Inclusion of this type involves enriching and expanding the existing unit in the syllabi of the accommodating subject areas to include population education related ideas. In this approach examples can be substituted into the already existing materials by population related examples. Through the substitution of examples, education content remains the same, only the substance of the example changes. This infusion was done either by incorporating in the textbooks or by publishing them in teacher guides. In other words, infusion with existing subject of population education concept means that no major curriculum reorganization is necessary. Time table need not be disturbed and existing teachers can teach with very little training.

This approach has also some demerits. In this approach, there is danger of fragmentation of the programme and the consequent failure of the pupil to attain the kind of understanding that the programme requires. It is much easier to see integration on paper than it is to achieve it in the reality of the school situation. It has been observed that population education concepts tend to be lost in the process of integration and the whole purpose of population education gets diffused.

In India efforts have been made to develop and integrate a few separate lessons as well as to infuse some ideas in the syllabi and textbooks of various subject areas at different school stages.

Population Education Conceptual Framework

- Historical Perspective

Another important question needs answer for curriculum development is the conceptual framework of Population Education. The concept of Population Education has relatively a short history. Ever since its inception, it has been changing and evolving at relatively faster pace. This has been so primarily because its central subject - the population phenomenon - has been unfolding itself in quick succession and identifying new dimensions of its interrelationships with other facets of human development. Alva Myrdal was perhaps the first to raise voice for the need of education in respect to the then population situation of western societies in 1941. Later in 1960, the noted teacher educators like Professor Sloan R. Wayland Warren S. Thompson and Philip M. Hauser conceptualized it as an education for making students aware of the demographic concerns focused on population growth.

In India also, Population Education was first conceptualized during the later half of nineteen sixties. The National Seminar on Population Education held in 1969 defined it as an education to make learner aware of the causes and effects of population changes. Initially Population Education emerged as a demographic- laden concept. In early part of Seventies, the Conceptual Framework of Population Education was built around the following six major areas.

1. The population growth

2. Economic development and population

3. Social development and population

4. Health nutrition and population

5. Biological factors - family life and population

6. Environment and Population

But with the passage of time, it was realized that it should be oriented toward values and therefore a need was felt to reconceptualize it.

The first reconceptualization occurred during late 1980s, when the Population Education Conceptual Framework focused on six major themes. Family size and Family Welfare; Delayed Marriage; Responsible Parenthood; Population Change and Resource Development, Population Related Values and Beliefs and Status of Women. The content focusing on these themes were drawn from six the following content areas. These were:

1. Population and Economic Development

2. Population and Social Development

3. Population and Family Life

4. Population Health and Nutrition

5. Population and Environmental Resources

6. Population Dynamics.

The concept of Population Education was reoriented to become value laden as population issues are predominantly value-laden.

By early 1990 again a need was felt to reconceputalize Population Education. The feedback received through in-built monitoring and findings of evaluation studies identified two basic limitations. These were:

1. Population Education Framework did not provide comprehensive treatment to the unfolding dimensions of relationship between population and development; and

2. Its theoretical framework was not in tune with the existing National Curriculum Framework of School Education in India.

The Core Curricular areas emphasized in the National Policy of Education, 1986, such as Observance of Small Family Norm, Equality of Sexes, Protection of Environment, Removal of Social Barriers and Inculcation of Scientific Temper were also to be reflected. The basic change in the perception of population development inter-relationship reflected in the ICPD Programme of Action registered a Paradigm Shift and put forth a fresh population agenda for the nations. The experiences gained during the implementation of NPEP in India also highlighted the gap regarding some crucial areas concerning sex-related matters, HIV/AIDS and Drug Abuse.

In view of the above the existing framework of population education is in the process of being reconceptualized with the following highlights:

1. The focus of population education will shift from number to essential conditions for population stabilization. These conditions are: Gender Equity and Equlity; Reproductive Health and Reproductive Rights- Family - Its Structure and Role, Sustainable Development and so on. It will highlight the individual needs instead of demographic targets and reflect the shift from purely population control to broader sustainable development approach.

2. It will highlight education as an essential condition for population stabilization.

3. The New framework will incorporate the elements of Adolescence Education (Process of Growing up, HIV/AIDS and Drug Abuse) as one of its major components.

4. Population Education will be conceptualized as a truly educational approach.

5. The Policy directions of Revised NPE 1992 will also be reflected in the Reconceptualised Framework of Population Education.

Definition of Population Education

UNESCO Regional Office for Education in Asia in 1970 defined Population Education "as an educational programme which provides for a study of the population situation in the family, the community, nation and the world with the purpose of developing in the students rational and responsible attitudes or behaviour toward that situation. In view of the ICPD Programme of Action, in the Reconceptualized Framework of Population Education, it has been defined "as an educational process to develop in learners an understanding of inter-relationships between population and development, causes and consequences of population change and the criticality of the conditions for population stabilization. It inculcates among them rational attitude and responsible behaviour towards population and development issues, so that they may make informed decisions".

Objectives of Population Education

The process of curriculum development should take into consideration the following objectives of population education :

• Making learners aware of the inter-relationships between population and sustainable development.

• Developing in them an understanding of the criticality of essential conditions of population stabilization for better quality of life of present and future generations.

• Inculcating in them rational attitude and responsible behaviour towards population and development issues.

• Making them understand the crucial aspects of adolescent reproductive health, focusing on the elements of process of growing up, and implication of HIV/AIDS and Drug Abuse.

• Inculcating in them rational attitude towards sex and drugs and promoting respect for the opposite sex; and

• Empowering them to take informed decisions on issues of population and development including reproductive health.

Identification of Population Education Contents

Population Education is a value-laden concept. Its content is culture and region specific and inter-disciplinary in nature. The desirability of having need-based as well as a demand based curriculum calls for a serious exercise in respect of selecting appropriate and relevant contents. The Reconceptulized Framework of Population Education has been built around the following six major themes :

1. Population and Sustainable Development

2. Gender Equality and Empowerment of Women

3. Adolescents Reproductive Health

4. Family : Socio-Economic Factors and Quality of Life

5. Health and Education

6. Population Distribution : Urbanization and Migration

The broad contents, theme-wise and stage-wise have been identified alongwith subjects with which these could be integrated. These are given below in tabular form.

Broad Contents of Population Education

Themes Broad content areas School stages Subjects
Population and Population Situation - Upper Primary Social Sciences
Sustainable Development Implications for Population   Stabilization Secondary Co-Curricular Activities
  Population and Sustained Economic Growth, Population and Poverty Secondary
Hr. S econdary
S. Sciences Economics, Geography, Pol. Science Sociology
  Consumption & Utilization of Resources, Avoidance Primary Upper Primary of wastage EVS/Social   Science
  Sustainable patterns and Levels of resource utilization, Production and consumption Secondary Hr. Secondary S. Sciences/Sociology/ Economics/Geography
  Population Resource and Technology Secondary Hr. Secondary S. Sciences/ Economics/ Geography/Sociology
  Environment, Development & population inter-relationship Secondary
Hr. Secondary
Economics/ Geography/ Sociology
Gender Equality and Empowerment of women The girl child equal treatment of boys and girls; Primary Lang/EVS Co-curricular activities
  Elimination of discrimination Upper Primary Lang/S. Sciences Co-curricular Activities
  Equity and Equality between man and woman in different aspects of life Secondary
Hr. Secondary
S. Sciences Sociology Co-curricularActivities
Themes Broad content areas
Promoting the fulfillment of women’s potential
School stages Secondary
Hr. Secondary
Subjects
S. Sciences
Sociology
  Empowerment of women Secondary
Hr. Secondary
S. Sciences
Sociology
  Participation of women in all aspects of life Secondary  
Hr. Secondary
S. Sciences
Sociology
  Reproduction health and Reproduction right Secondary  
Hr. Secondary
S. Sciences
Sociology
  Male responsibility in all areas of family and household activity Secondary
Hr. Secondary
S. Sciences  
Sociology
  Reproductive rights Secondary S. Sciences
Hr. Secondary
Sociology
Adolescents Reproductive
Health
Physical growth in human body, Genital hygiene Primary EVS/Co-Curricular Activities
  Physical, emotional changes during adolescence, inter- personal relationships sexua lHealth and Hygiene, Myths and Misconception Physical, physiological and Psychological development during adolescence Upper Primar Secondary 
Hr. Secondary
Sciences/S.Sciences/ Biology/Psych.Health and physical Edu Co-curricular Activities
  Conception and Pregnancy Contraceptive methods Adolescent pregnancy and its consequences. " "
  Interpersonal relationships between adolescents and members of the opposite sex Parents, peer group and gender Roles.    
  Meaning of HIV, AIDS, Modes of Transmission, ways through which HIV Upper Primary Secondary
Higher
Sciences,
S. Sciences/Bio. Health and Physical Education/
Themes Broad content areas is not transmitted, Ways of preventing HIV transmission School stages Secondary Subjects Co-Curricular Activities
  Drug Abuse, and its Implication, Prevention & Rehabilitation of Drug Abuse, Myths and Misconceptions Secondary
Higher Secondary
Science, Bio./
S. Sciences/Sociology/ Co-Curricular Activities
Family Socio-Economic Factors and Quality of Life Family as a basic unit of Society Family & basic needs of family members Primary
Upper Primary
Language+ Environmental Studies/Civics              Co- CurricularActivities
  Shared roles and responsibilities of all the members in the family    
 

Marriage & Family, Socio-economic development & their impact on patterns of family composition

   
  Shared roles and responsibilities of the members particularly the participation of women in decision making Secondary/ Higher Secondary Political Science Sociology
 

Elimination of discrimination against girl child, elimination of all types of violence against girls and women; and

   
 

Equal opportunities for Members for education, employment, responsible parenthood

   
Health & Education Health, Cleanliness of surrounding, Safe drinking water, Importance of Immunization Primary Health Care Primary/ Upper Primary EVS/Science/ Language
Themes Broad content areas

Child survival, Spacing, Reproductive Health of mother, Child Care

Health of Women and Safe Motherhood, Improvement in nutritional Status especially of pregnant and lactating mother Pre and Post-natal care
School stages

Secondary 


Secondary
Higher Secondary


Subjects

Science

Science/
Biology
Sociology



Population Distribution Urbanization and Migration
Population Distribution- Concept of Urbanization

- Population growth in urban areas and socioeconomic civic & environmental challenges
Secondary Higher   SecondaryGeography/ Sociology

Secondary
Higher Secondary
Social Sciences/ Economics/

Economics/
Geography/
Sociology
 

- Problems of urban agglomeration

   
 

- Need for Sustainable regional development strategies

   
  - Migration - Causes and Impact Upper Primary Secondary Higher Secondary Social Sciences

Curriculum Transaction

The changes reflected in the Conceptual Framework of Population Education will require identification and adoption of suitable strategies of curriculum transaction. The strategy of integration of population education contents into the syllabi and textbooks of selected subjects at the school level has been adopted. The textbooks are considered effective instruments for exposing students to population education ideas and messages that are essential for making their understanding of population phenomena better. In this context the following strategies may be useful:

(i) Attempt has to be made to include only those contents that could receive comprehensive and effective treatment in the syllabi and textbooks of concerned subjects. Those natural entry points be selected that have potentiality of providing comprehensive treatment to relevant population education contents. The most crucial aspect of effective integration would be to integrate maximum contents at minimum points in most comprehensive way. Only those subjects should be given priority that have greater potentiality to incorporate these contents.

(ii) Some contents of population education may not find suitable entry into the existing syllabi and textbooks because of the limitation of the subject areas. For such contents supplementary reading materials and ‘audio-visual materials may be developed. Classroom teaching needs to be supplemented by a variety of co-curricular activities such as project assignments, play way activities, demonstration, group discussion, painting, essay writing, debate, elocution, question box, quiz competition, etc.

(iii) Any curriculum remains a futile exercise unless it is put into practice. Teacher occupies an important place in the implementation of this area. It is the teacher who has to use the material, create learning situations in the classroom for their students and help them to learn. Their orientation to the new curriculum is, therefore, absolutely essential. Both in-service and pre-service orientation should be organized. The teacher should be fed with suitable instructional materials like teacher’s guide, handbooks with update information and audio-visual materials.

Population education taught by an imaginative teacher could enable students to creative thinking and action in relation to a number of problems and issues that surround them. Problem solving/discovery approach and value clarification approaches are regarded to be more functional.

(iv) The population education contents integrated in different subject areas, other materials developed for promoting effective integration, teacher training organized and activities conducted in schools should be evaluated to find out whether the desired outcomes in terms of awareness and attitude have been achieved. Being value-laden, continuous and comprehensive evaluation should be followed so that necessary improvements are made in the curriculum and materials and its transaction.

References :

1. Jayasuriya, J.E. (1978) Curriculum innovation through population education. Colombo : Associated Educational Publishers.

2. Kline, David and David Harman. (1976) ed. Issues in population education Lexington, Mass. : Lexington Books.

3. NCERT, (1998) Minimum essential contents of population Education, NPEP, DESSH, NCERT, New Delhi : (Mimeographed)

4. National Council of Educational Research and Training. (1972) Population Education Cell, Population education : selected readings. New Delhi.

5 . National Council of Educational Research and Training. (1980) Population education Tasks and challenges, New Delhi.

6. National Council of Educational Research and Training, Draft syllabus on population education, New Delhi : (Memographed)

7. Paper prepared by Dr. R.C. Sharma, Regional Advisor for In-school Population Education, for National seminar on integration of population education in school curriculum, held in Human Province, China, October 1986.

8. Sikes, O.J. Reconceptualization of population education, Technical Paper Number 2, UNFPA, New York : 1993

9. Unesco. Regional Office for Education in Asia and the Pacific. Problems and strategies for curriculum development in population education. A paper presented to the Group Training course in Population Education, Bangkok : 14 July to 15 August 1975.

10. Unesco. Regional Office for Education in Asia and the Pacific. (1980) Population education: innovative structures and approaches. Report of a Regional Workshop, New Delhi, 23-29 October 1979. Bangkok : Unesco.

11. Unesco. Regional Office for Education in Asia and the Pacific. (1978) Future directions of population education. Report of a Regional Consultative Seminar, Manila, 14-21 August 1978. Bangkok.